CFS, M.E. and fibromyalgia could be re-classified as “mental disorders”

[Edit 13th Feb: The WHO has confirmed on Twitter that they have no plans to reclassify the conditions, and that their site is a BETA site for health professionals to contribute to. However the work of Dr. Fink still persists and these misdiagnoses of CFS/M.E./fibromyalgia still occur and are still just as dangerous so I feel the point this blog post makes is still just as relevant and important.]

This afternoon, a load of posts appeared on Twitter about an article that had appeared on the Liberty Voice website.The article was titled “Fibromyalgia and ME/CFS Labeled Mental and Behavioral Disorders by WHO” and has, understandably caused a whole load of panic among the fibro/M.E/CFS community. The fight to get these diseases correctly classified as physiological rather than psychological has been long and on-going, and this seems a big step back in the wrong direction.

As I type, the article has been taken down – we don’t know why. This is a link to an image of the article before it was removed so you can read it, but the basic gist of it was that Dr Per Fink, a psychiatrist from Denmark, has classified fibromyalgia, CFS and M.E. as a “bodily distress disorder”. According to the WHO website:

“Bodily distress disorder is characterized by high levels of preoccupation regarding bodily symptoms, unusually frequent or persistent medical help-seeking, and avoidance of normal activities for fear of damaging the body.”

Bodily distress disorder is classified on the WHO classifications as a “mental and behavioral disorder”. This means that fibromyalgia, CFS and M.E. will be classified as something that has to be treated as a psychological illness, rather than a physical one. This is very problematic. Although psychological illnesses are valid illnesses that need to be treated correctly, treating a physical condition as a psychological one does not work. You cannot treat cancer solely by sending someone to group therapy, you cannot treat M.E. solely by sending someone to CBT.

Dr. Fink runs a clinic called The Research Clinic for Functional Disorders and Psychosomatics. On his website, he classifies conditions such as fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue syndrome and irritable bowel syndrome as “bodily distress syndromes”. He feels that these conditions are all the same thing, that if a condition can’t be diagnosed in testing (such as arthritis) then it is a psychological disorder. This clinic is currently responsible for Karina Hansen, a 24 year old with M.E. who was forcibly removed from her home to go to the clinic and get treatment.

Classifying genuine physical conditions as psychological is dangerous. It will mean people will get the wrong treatment and will not be given any opportunities to improve their condition. In a lot of cases, it will make their condition worse. There is a lot of discussion in the M.E. community about graded exercise therapy and how successful or otherwise that is, and I’m planning on compiling some info about that for another post. However, regardless of whether these treatments work for some or otherwise, treating a physical illness as a psychological one means people who have these conditions will be mis-diagnosed and mis-treated.

It also de-legitimises the people who have these conditions. Psychological illnesses are very valid illnesses of course, but to tell someone that the pain and debilitating fatigue they suffer from is a psychological problem is, quite frankly, offensive.

On her blog, fibrogirl has suggested some ideas for action:

1. Research – pull it all together fully referenced in one place, including bloggers links etc
2. Lobby 
3. share our stories – our truths 
4. Galvanise the online community, our friends and loved ones to make a bloody big noise – that is coordinated and focused
5. leave a reply here if you are willing to help. Im just one scared angry voice – I cant do anything alone. I’m not an academic, or even a very good writer. but surely if all the bloggers, academics, medics who believe in us and we make enough of a stink we might just finally break through and get what we deserve...a true diagnosis and treatment that helps us manage these disabling illnesses

I totally agree with what she says. I am a relative newcomer to this community, there are many people out there who have been fighting this battle for years. However I feel I have a duty to educate myself on this, and to share the information I find out in a way that might make it easier for people to understand the problems we’re facing. I agree with fibrogirl – we need to step up the fight and start making a bigger noise.

Fibrogirl’s post

Spoonydoc’s post

Advertisements

4 Comments on “CFS, M.E. and fibromyalgia could be re-classified as “mental disorders””

  1. Rachel Morris says:

    The world health organisation classified M.E as a neurological disorder in 1969 and its incorrect to suggest there are no tests for M.E there are tests its just the doctors aren’t currently educated enough to use them or to actually bother to use the diagnosis of M.E, fibro etc as anything other than waste paper basket diagnosis. I suggest you take a look at The Hummingbirds guide to M.E. website where you will find a whole host of medical papers that prove there are tests available to “prove” an M.E diagnosis.
    Its such a shame that these idiot Drs decide that they know more than the world leading experts in the field. However MS was treated the same way initially and sufferers were treated as hysterical basket cases.
    Educate yourself and your doctors and look at the website I have recommended which has a wealth of information contained within it and is backed by Dr Byron Hyde and Dr Dowsett ( sorry if my spelling of their names is incorrect but I’m very ill myself at the moment) two leading experts in M.E.

    • Emsy says:

      Hi Rachel, I’ve looked at Hummingbirds and there’s a massive amount of info on there so I’m taking time to read through it. I’m in the process of finding out as much as I can – as I said I’m a relative newcomer to this, I am in fact still waiting for my own diagnoses. Either way, the fact that there are people like Fink out there concerns me a lot, and it means people are taking theories like his seriously.

  2. […] CFS, M.E. and fibromyalgia could be re-classified as “mental disorders” → […]

  3. […] where we’ve seen that term used before? Our friend Dr. Fink, who considers these conditions to be mental disorders. So that’s concerning, for a […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s